Profit fell 29%, but per-share profit fell 22% after buybacks
Asbury Automotive still made money. Net income was $105.10 M this quarter, a 2% margin on $4.41 B of sales, down from $147.10 M a year earlier. Sales fell 8% in the same span, and cost of sales took $83.43 of every $100 of sales. Its profit margin, at 2% of sales, is thin for a company of this size. Cost of sales is the biggest number on the page, at $3.68 B for the quarter.
The per-share number fell less than profit did. Earnings per share fell 22% to $5.84, while net income fell 29%. The gap is the share count: the average diluted count dropped 8%, to 18.0 M from 19.6 M. Diluted shares count the shares that options and awards could add, so they are the stricter measure. The filing says it repurchased 1,346,359 shares for $277.60 M in the nine months, and it bought back no stock in the quarter itself.
Two things hold the quarter together: the tax rate and the buybacks. The tax rate fell to 24.4% from 26.5%, so profit after tax fell less than profit before tax. Selling and overhead costs rose to 11.4% of sales from 11.0%, the wrong direction for a company that needs its costs to fall. Will per-share profit keep outrunning profit if the buybacks stop and the tax rate returns to 26.5%?

