Dealerships make 98% of sales at a 4.2% operating margin
Asbury Automotive's dealerships are nearly the whole business. They brought in $4.33 B of revenue this quarter, 98% of the total. TCA brought in $82.60 M. Dealerships kept 4.2% of their sales as operating income, while TCA kept 25%. The two businesses sum to the consolidated total, so little is left for anything else to explain. Every other part of the company is too small to move these figures much. That is the picture to hold before reading the profit story.
Why did profit fall? Dealerships' operating income dropped $32.30 M, from $213.90 M to $181.60 M, while TCA's rose from $19.60 M to $20.70 M. Combined, the segments' operating profit fell $31.20 M. The combined margin slipped 0.3 percentage points, and the business mix barely moved, so the decline came from inside the businesses. The profit line is the one that moved, and it moved in the dealerships. Dealerships' profit fell 15.1% while its sales fell 8.2%.
TCA earns 1.9% on $1.10 B of assets, almost the same return as Dealerships' 1.8% on $10.06 B. The margin gap is about sales, not capital. TCA is by far the smaller business, so its 25% margin adds only a little to the company total. The dealerships, which hold 90% of the assets, set the company's return on capital. Will TCA's 25% margin hold as its product revenue is earned over the life of each contract?

