Dealerships make 98% of segment sales; TCA keeps 25% as operating profit
Asbury Automotive's dealerships carry the company. They brought in $4.41 B of segment sales this quarter, 98% of the total. The other segment, TCA, brought in $82.60 M, the rest of the business. The profit picture flips the ranking: TCA kept 25% of its sales as operating income, against 4.1% for the dealerships. TCA's share of profit is far larger than its share of sales. That gap, not the sales line, is the real story for anyone valuing the company.
Why does the profit fall? Dealerships' operating income dropped $32.30 M from a year earlier, from $213.90 M to $181.60 M, while TCA's rose from $19.60 M to $20.70 M. Combined, the segments' operating profit fell $31.20 M. The combined operating margin slipped 0.3 percentage points, and the business mix barely moved. So the decline came from inside the businesses, not from a change in what the company sells. Here is the wrinkle: the two segments' operating profit adds to $202.30 M, while consolidated operating income is $206.60 M.
Two numbers carry the argument. Dealerships hold 90% of the segments' assets, $10.06 B, and earn 1.8% on them, while TCA earns 1.9% on $1.10 B. The 25% margin belongs to a small unit that earns its revenue over the life of each contract, so it is not a sign that the dealerships are about to improve. Will that 25% margin hold as those contracts run, or is it a product of how the revenue is recognized?

